Hello dear
Welcome To El Molcajete Mexican Food
El Molcajete Mexican Food, located in Flemington, NJ, is a hidden gem for authentic Mexican cuisine. Featuring a diverse menu, the restaurant delights diners with dishes like Barbacoa En Salsa and Chiles Rellenos, all crafted with fresh ingredients. Regulars rave about the homemade tortilla chips and flavorful guacamole. Whether you're indulging in comforting Chicken Nachos or the savory Chuleta Molcajete, each bite encapsulates a rich, traditional taste. The warm and inviting atmosphere, coupled with friendly service, makes it a must-visit. Frequent patrons emphasize its quality, suggesting that this delightful spot is worth any trip.
Today's Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
Pollo
Fajitas De Camarones
Camarones A La Diabla
Mini Burrito
About
El Molcajete Mexican Food
Welcome to El Molcajete Mexican Food, a culinary treasure nestled on Old Croton Road in Flemington, NJ. At this charming eatery, you'll discover the vibrant and rich flavors of authentic Mexican cuisine, crafted with passion and precision. As a food reviewer for Foodjoyy, I'm excited to share my experience and insights into this delightful establishment.
From the moment you step through the door, the welcoming atmosphere and friendly staff invite you to indulge in a menu that features tantalizing dishes sure to please any palate. Signature plates like the Barbacoa En Salsa ($17.99) and Bistec Encebollado ($17.49) showcase the bold, succulent flavors that define Mexican dining. The highlight for many diners is undoubtedly the El Molcajete ($29.99), a vibrant medley of fresh ingredients served in a traditional stone mortar that perfectly embodies the essence of this cuisine.
Customer reviews consistently praise El Molcajete as a hidden gem. Many have raved about the chicken nachos, where crunchy, homemade tortilla chips blanket tender, marinated chicken and melted cheese, topped off with their zesty red salsa. One excited diner, Paige Peck, drives from Watchung just to savor this dish—such is the allure of truly homemade Mexican fare. Another guest, Ozzie, could hardly contain his enthusiasm for the guacamole and enchiladas, noting the exceptional freshness and rich flavors crafted from quality ingredients.
One of the best aspects of El Molcajete is its dedication to quality and authenticity in every bite. With dishes like Chiles Rellenos ($16.49) and Milanesa De Pollo ($13.49), it’s clear the culinary team is committed to delivering the true essence of Mexican food. Several patrons have praised their delectable Camarones A La Diabla ($17.49), which adds a tantalizing kick to the menu, showcasing the restaurant's ability to balance rich flavors with just the right amount of heat.
While some diners mention occasional wait times, the consensus is that the incredible food makes every minute worthwhile. El Molcajete stands out not just as a restaurant, but as a community favorite—an eatery that feels more like home with each visit. Whether you are a local or just passing through, this hidden gem promises a memorable dining experience that will keep you coming back for more.
In summary, El Molcajete Mexican Food is a must-visit for anyone seeking a taste of authentic Mexican culture and cuisine in Flemington. With satisfying portions, exceptional flavors, and a heartwarming ambiance, this establishment encapsulates what it means to indulge in truly outstanding Mexican food.
For inquiries and to plan your visit, feel free to call them at +1 908-237-1553. Don’t miss out on this delightful culinary journey!
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ Legit as they come highly recommended! In an area where you might not expect but definitely worth the ride. Don't be fooled the food is worth the ride back! Those chimichangas were #unreal ”
“ Hidden gem. The food was so good. The guacamole was fresh and flavorful. Homemade tortilla chips were amazing. I ordered the chicken empanadas and was shocked at how good they were. Finally, I got the enchiladas. I got them with the red sauce. They were just right for me, but I recommend the green sauce if you are not used to spicy food. Will be definitely returning. The menu looks like it used to have Tortas. Hopefully, they bring those back. They are perfect for lunch. Sorry, there are no pictures of the empanadas. They were gone before I could take a pic. ”
“ Cannot rave enough on the chicken nachos. The simplest dish- chips, shredded marinated chicken, and melted cheese. All 3 of the ingredients are so fresh and good. The chips alone make it, they’re crunchy! Homemade. And the red salsa, don’t get me started. It’s my absolute favorite. I drive from Watchung NJ to get this by the jar, almost weekly. Highly highly recommend for authentic Mexican. ”
“ This spot is delicious! I came here for dinner, I live out of town and no one was here. The food was great! There was a small wait, but between online orders and a couple people coming in there was only one or two people working. Food this good from a small family business is awesome. ”
“ This place is a hidden gem. Finally stopped for dinner last night and it was incredible. Atmosphere is really neat and inviting. Staff is friendly and the food.... incredible. Highly recommend. June 2025 Update: this place is still fantastic, but they seem to operate with business hours known only to them. What's shown on Google is no longer accurate, and there have been multiple times we've called ahead to see if they were open, and it either rang a few times before going to voicemail--or went straight to voicemail. Hope they can "course correct" soon because they're a great local business. ”
“ We’d been getting recommendations for this restaurant forever and finally decided to give it a shot and we were so glad we did. We arrived on the earlier side and it was a one woman show with our hostess taking our order and heading to the back to cook one delicious plate after the other! I highly recommend the tacos al pastor but everything was fantastic! The food was also very reasonably priced which was impressive considering how apparent it was that each thing was being individually prepared. The guacamole was the best I’ve ever had! ”
“ Food was excellent. Very generous size portions of real authentic home cooking. Prices are very fair. Parking is tight. Be ready for a wait as they usually have one server/cook. But worth the wait. Excellent atmosphere, plenty to enjoy while waiting. ”
“ Love this place. My wife and I lived in the area for 3 years before we stopped in to check it out. What a regret. It's a real mom and pop shop serving up delicious Mexican food. We order take out from here pretty often now. Get the chorizo burritos, you won't be let down! ”